2 History of the ban
1. Local 550 and the origin of the ban
In the early 1940s, a group of Black workers at UVA hospital formed a labor union: Local 550 of the State, County, and Municipal Workers of America. As was typical of the Jim Crow South, UVA’s hospital was segregated physically—with inferior facilities for Black patients—and in terms of employment, with Black employees systematically confined to less-desirable positions, lower wages, and longer hours.
Local 550 used coordinated walkouts and work stoppages to push back against workplace segregation—winning remarkable victories for Black workers, including wage increases, a guaranteed eight-hour workday, and an end to segregation in some workplace divisions. However, their victory was short-lived. Recognizing the power of an organized Black working class, segregationist politicians acted quickly to ban collective bargaining.
[Heading Here]
After 26 Black women employed as ward maids leveraged the power of collective action and walked off the job in 1943, UVA was forced to the bargaining table. In this letter to UVA President John Lloyd Newcomb, three Black community leaders (T.J. Sellers, Reverend E. Lloyd Jemison, and Douglas Edwards) argue that UVA’s hospital doesn’t pay its Black workers a living wage and request that Newcomb meet with the committee. In his reply, Newcomb refuses to meet with the committee as a group and instead offers to negotiate individually with the ward maids. As we’ve seen, individual contract negotiations favor management whereas collective bargaining offers workers a much stronger negotiating position.
[Not digitized]
Letter from J.L. Newcomb to T.J. Sellers (Feb. 2, 1943). Papers of the President, 1943-1944 (RG-2/1/2.541).
[Not digitized]
Letter from T.J. Sellers, Reverend E. Lloyd Jemison, and Douglas Edwards to J.L. Newcomb (Jan. 24, 1943). Papers of the President, 1943-1944 (RG-2/1/2.541).
The Origins of Local 550
In the spring of 1945, these workers decided to form a union—Local 550 of the State, County, and Municipal Workers of America—to advocate for themselves collectively. By that summer, Local 550 had organized 80% of the hospital’s Black workforce and successfully obtained recognition from UVA’s administration, most likely because the administration recognized that a coordinated work stoppage would have completely shut down the hospital. Through collective bargaining, Local 550’s members managed to win better hours, benefits, and wages.
[Not digitized]
C.S. Lentz, Biennium Report of the UVA Hospital Superintendent (Jan. 16, 1946). Annual Reports to the President 1945-1946 (RG-2/1/1.381).
1946 Collective Bargaining Ban
Just a few months after Local 550’s successful negotiations, Virginia’s 1946 General Assembly passed Senate Joint Resolution No. 12 banning collective bargaining by public-sector workers—at the request of Virginia Governor William Tuck.

The timing wasn’t a coincidence. As shown in this contemporary article found by Matthew Conover, a nurse in UVA’s Pediatric ICU and member of UCW-VA’s Joint Steering Committee, Governor Tuck called for the ban directly after meeting with UVA President Newcomb. This article also notes that Local 550 “is believed here to be the only organized group of State workers in Virginia,” meaning that this statewide ban did not actually apply to any other groups.
An author of the Stanley Plan of “massive resistance” to school desegregation, Governor Tuck was a member of the infamous “Byrd Machine” of conservative Democrats in Virginia—a rear-guard, anti-Civil Rights Movement effort to uphold anti-miscegenation laws and segregation of the military, among other dubious causes. On February 8, the General Assembly officially passed Tuck’s proposed resolution.

“CIO Is Refused Contract at University.” Richmond Times-Dispatch, V. 98, No. 28 (January 28, 1946).
The Beam: Local 550’s Newsletter
Even without the right to collectively bargain, Local 550 continued advocating for Black workers’ rights. Their weekly newsletter, The Beam, informed members about political events on the local, regional, and national scale and also served as an avenue for building and articulating a sense of community. Issue 52 celebrated the publication’s “first birthday” with a meditation on this “little paper with much punch.” In this issue, the anonymous authors also draw an explicit connection between the struggles for civil and labor rights, observing that Southern politicians and Northern corporations alike fear that “adoption of a real civil rights program would encourage the growth of unionism below the Mason-Dixon Line.”
[Not digitized]
United Public Workers of America Local 550, The Beam, 52nd edition (Aug. 16, 1948). (HD6350.H7 B4)
2. The Ban Becomes Law
The 1948 joint resolution made the ban official state policy, but it didn’t become a law until 1993. In the period between those two dates, UVA employees did make some attempts to form unions, even as Virginia politicians from both major parties took steps to ensure that collective bargaining rights would remain out of reach for public-sector workers.
[Heading Here]
This flier was distributed by a mysterious group identified by an acronym clearly intended to reference UVA’s history of enslaved labor. By “fixing” an advertisement published in The Daily Progress, the flier argues that UVA should offer workers better wages and benefits, echoing Local 550’s similar demands three decades earlier. One of the SLAVE Society’s proposed solutions was a statewide labor union for public-sector employees.
[Not digitized]
SLAVE Society, “slaves” flier. Richmond: Black Flag Press, 1973. (RG-24/45/1.101)
Arlington Decision
Not long afterward , a group of county employees in Arlington, Virginia, voted to unionize with the State, County, and Municipal Workers of America, after which the County recognized the union and negotiated a contract via collective bargaining. Three other public employee unions in Arlington followed suit, representing firefighters, teachers, and school administrators. Their contract agreements included wages, hours, benefits, and grievance procedures.
In response, Democratic Virginia Governor Mills E. Godwin—like Governor Tuck, a defender of “massive resistance” and member of the Byrd Machine—directed his Attorney General to sue the Arlington County Board, arguing that these contract negotiations were illegal. When the court ruled against Godwin, allowing collective bargaining on the grounds that “the public policy of Virginia does not prohibit the actions taken” in explicit language, the Godwin administration appealed to the Virginia Supreme Court, citing the 1946 joint resolution passed under Tuck’s recommendation. The conservative-controlled court agreed with the Governor’s argument, declaring the collectively bargained contracts void, and handed down a precedent that prevented other public-sector unions from attempting to bargain similar contracts.
“By the end of the 1970s,” mused historian James C. Cobb, “anti-unionism had supplanted racism as the South’s most respectable prejudice.”
Harold materials [didn’t end up in exhibition, but still in this Google doc: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1u6U5VysoeUsSfXOAx5PMNRlOKhDzhNX8iRS5rzIZjd0/edit]
The Union Label
On March 29, 1993, Virginia’s first Black governor, L. Douglas Wilder, signed into law HB 1872/SB 962, which officially prohibited collective bargaining by government employees. The bill had passed both houses of the General Assembly easily, with strong bipartisan support, and the legislation didn’t get much press at the time—“perhaps,” the scholar Dane M. Partridge has suggested, “because public policy in Virginia with respect to public employee bargaining had been clear since at least 1977,” when Virginia’s Supreme Court had issued the Arlington decision.
Why was Governor Wilder interested in banning public-sector collective bargaining a full sixteen years after that Supreme Court decision? The new law may have been a compromise between the demands of organized big business and labor unions: the ban included language protecting “dues checkoffs” (a mechanism allowing employees to have union dues deducted directly from their payrolls), which had nearly been banned in a previous legislative session.
As this anti-union editorial from the Richmond Times-Dispatch shows, both Republicans and conservative Democrats saw the ban as a matter of some urgency, referring to dues checkoffs and collective bargaining as “complementary mischief” and advancing the specious argument that legal collective bargaining would lead to public employee strikes, which were explicitly prohibited by law.

“The Union Label.” Richmond Times-Dispatch, V. 143, No. 34 (Feb. 3, 1993).
3. The Beginning of the End of the Ban?
Throughout this section, we’ve seen that the story of collective bargaining is inseparable from Virginia’s history of structural racism. Both labor groups and their adversaries understood that racial justice depends on economic justice and that collective bargaining is a powerful tool for economic justice. As Virginians’ labor rights have been gradually restored over the past few years, It’s fitting that the story of Local 550 has been part of the struggle.
Hudson quote [re-add Hudson’s testimony from the Google Doc: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1u6U5VysoeUsSfXOAx5PMNRlOKhDzhNX8iRS5rzIZjd0/edit]
2020: Partial Overturn of the Collective Bargaining Ban
On April 22, 2020, with Democratic control of Virginia’s State Senate, House of Delegates, and governorship, the General Assembly partially overturned the ban. The new law retained the language of the original but with a significant unless clause: public-sector collective bargaining was banned unless a “city, county or town” passed an ordinance or resolution allowing their employees to collectively bargain. Governor Ralph Northam signed the law, which went into effect on May 1, 2021.
By any standard, this is a weak collective bargaining law because employees who wish to collectively bargain with their employer must first petition that same employer for the right to do so. This amended version of the law also didn’t mention state workers, meaning that such workers were still implicitly banned from bargaining under the original text of the law.
Talking Union
Talking Union is a podcast produced by the United Campus Workers of Virginia, focusing in particular on the “wall-to-wall” practice commonly used by the UCW. The podcast includes perspectives from VCU and UVA, from parents, from transgender union members, and from those engaged with the history of unions. Running for six episodes, the podcast provides a glimpse into the life of a union member, centering the people involved.
2022: Charlottesville’s Collective Bargaining Ordinance
On October 4, 2022, Charlottesville City Council unanimously passed an ordinance allowing collective bargaining for several categories of city employees, including Charlottesville Area Transit. At the time, both the interim city manager and city councilors themselves suggested that the ordinance (along with a raise for bus drivers) was passed in large part to attract new drivers. In August of that year, Charlottesville’s public school division had announced that they only had eight school bus drivers— instead of the 40 drivers needed to staff all routes. After this ordinance was passed, CAT employees held a union election, voted to join the Amalgamated Transit Union, and began preparing to negotiate a contract.
Proposed 2024 law